Audit a civil success-fee invoice against the agreed terms
A judgment award and money actually received are different amounts, and the contractual definition of the fee base determines which is relevant.
This tool checks the arithmetic of one Korean civil representation agreement using your verified base, fee rate, payment trigger and credit order.
It does not recommend a market fee or estimate a success fee from the probability of winning.
Three things to review
- The agreed economic benefit, rate, minimum, cap and retainer credit.
- Net fee, VAT, prior success-fee payments, outstanding balance and invoice difference.
- Trigger verification, payment timing and cash needed before collection.
Defaults are a hypothetical example, not a standard rate or an appropriate price for your case.
Use the results alongside the contract, judgment or settlement, collection records and invoice.
All amounts are in KRW and the source context is Korean law checked in 2026.
Economic benefit is defined by the particular agreement
Civil Act Article 105 and Article 686 provide relevant principles on the parties’ agreement and remuneration for a mandate.
They do not make either judgment awards or cash collection the universal base for every civil success fee.
Separately confirm whether judgment delivery, final judgment, settlement, actual collection or another event triggers payment.
Supreme Court decision 2022Da293937, dated 2023-08-31, concerns the specific fee agreement and economic benefit in a property-division matter.
Its method is not a universal formula for all civil cases.
Choose defence benefit as opposing claim minus confirmed liability only when that is the verified contractual definition; otherwise use a confirmed custom base.
Clauses treating withdrawal, mediation, compromise, claim reduction or termination by the client as success require separate confirmation.
Record ambiguous wording in unresolved conditions and use only the hypothetical calculation until clarified.
The confirmation checkbox records your verification of inputs; it does not establish contractual validity or a legal obligation to pay.
Inputs that build the fee base
Judgment basis
Enter judgment principal and judgment interest separately.
They are added only when interest inclusion is selected; leave it off if the agreement excludes interest or delay damages.
Collection basis
Enter confirmed collected principal and interest independently.
Do not copy uncollected judgment money into this base or include expected future receipts as cash already collected.
Settlement or custom base
Enter a single total whose scope has been confirmed.
Judgment or collection interest is not added again.
For a special or combined contractual definition, calculate the base separately and document its construction in the base description.
Defence benefit
Where the agreement defines it this way, subtract confirmed liability from the opposing claim.
Liability exceeding the claim is an input error.
This benefit can exist without a cash receipt and must be distinguished from collected money.
The judgment and collection comparison rows are independent assumptions, never combined.
An invalid or blank unused comparison base leaves that row pending while a valid selected base can still be calculated.
Money inputs accept whole KRW from 0 to 1 trillion; the contractual rate accepts 0–100% with up to two decimal places.
A blank is not a confirmed zero.
Rate, minimum, cap and retainer-credit order
For base B and rate r, the rate fee R is B × r ÷ 100, rounded to the nearest KRW.
A minimum raises the calculated fee to a floor and a cap limits it.
An enabled cap below the minimum is invalid.
No cap and a cap of zero are different choices.
Verify one of three operation orders
- Minimum / cap → credit → tax: subtract the retainer from the limited fee, floor the result at zero, and apply the tax treatment.
- Credit → minimum / cap → tax: subtract the retainer from the rate fee first, then apply the limits, so the minimum may apply again after the credit.
- Minimum / cap → tax → credit: calculate the tax-inclusive total after the limits, then deduct the gross retainer payment credit.
Confirm whether any or all of the retainer is actually creditable against the success fee.
A credit above the relevant fee does not create a negative total; the unused portion is shown separately.
That figure does not establish a right to recover excess retainer payments.
There is no single credit order automatically applied to every agreement.
Separate added VAT, included VAT and confirmed tax
Add 10% VAT
The amount F reaching the tax step is the net fee: tax = F × 10%, rounded to the nearest KRW, and gross = F + tax.
The rate, minimum, cap and any pre-tax retainer credit must all use the net convention.
10% VAT already included
F is already gross: net = F ÷ 1.1, rounded to the nearest KRW, and tax = F − net.
The rate, minimum, cap and pre-tax credit use the gross convention in this mode.
For example, KRW 9,000,000 gross is split into net KRW 8,181,818 and tax KRW 818,182.
Confirmed tax or unknown treatment
You can enter a confirmed tax amount corresponding to the actual net fee.
The comparison keeps that same entered tax rather than scaling it, so verify tax separately for each alternative base.
Unknown tax treatment holds contract-payment confirmation; it does not mean tax law lacks a calculation rule.
VAT Act Article 30 sets the 10% rate, Article 29(3) excludes VAT from the taxable supply value, and Article 29(7) provides a consideration × 100/110 rule where VAT inclusion is unclear.
Determining the taxable supply value and deciding whether extra VAT may be charged under the agreement are different questions.
With a post-tax credit, the displayed net fee and tax precede that credit; the tool does not determine whether a tax invoice must be issued or corrected.
Nearest-KRW rounding is a tool assumption, not a universal legal rounding rule; check the agreement’s actual truncation or rounding convention.
Prior payment and the current invoice are separate
Outstanding balance = max(total after credit − prior success-fee payments, 0)
Excess-payment reference = max(prior success-fee payments − total after credit, 0)
Invoice difference = current payment request − outstanding balance
Prior payment means only success fees already paid, including their tax.
Do not enter a retainer again if it was already deducted as a credit.
Court filing, service, appraisal and enforcement advances are not success-fee payments.
If an invoice combines several items, isolate the success-fee portion being reviewed here.
A positive invoice difference means the request is above the calculated balance; a negative difference means it is below it.
Neither difference alone establishes an overcharge, error or refund right.
If the trigger or tax treatment remains unverified, the confirmed invoice difference is also held rather than presented as an established invoice error.
Payment trigger, due date and review date
- Trigger: verify judgment delivery, final judgment, settlement, collection or another agreed event, and select unverified, unmet or met.
- Event date: the date the confirmed event occurred; it cannot be later than the review date.
- Contractual due date: a separately confirmed payment date, not automatically the event date.
This audit model treats an entered due date before the confirmed event date as a date-order error; recheck the agreement and dates.
- Review date: the date used to check whether payment is due; update it for the review you are performing.
A user-confirmed balance requires confirmation of the contract terms, a base description, a verified event and its date, a due date, a known tax treatment and no unresolved-condition memo.
An unmet or unknown trigger holds confirmation rather than declaring the payment to be zero.
When the terms are confirmed but the due date is after the review date, the outstanding balance remains while payment due today is zero.
Changing inputs clears the contract confirmation.
Worked judgment-versus-collection example
Both hypothetical alternatives use a 10% rate, zero minimum, no cap, a KRW 2,000,000 retainer credit, minimum / cap → credit → tax, added 10% VAT and KRW 1,100,000 already paid as success fees.
These figures do not determine which basis the actual contract requires or whether the fee has arisen.
Hypothetical civil success-fee line items under judgment and collected bases, in KRW| Item | Judgment (KRW) | Collected (KRW) |
|---|
| Principal | 100,000,000 | 40,000,000 |
| Included interest | 10,000,000 | 2,000,000 |
| Base | 110,000,000 | 42,000,000 |
| Base × 10% | 11,000,000 | 4,200,000 |
| Net fee after retainer credit | 9,000,000 | 2,200,000 |
| 10% VAT | 900,000 | 220,000 |
| Total after credit | 9,900,000 | 2,420,000 |
| Success fees already paid | 1,100,000 | 1,100,000 |
| Outstanding balance | 8,800,000 | 1,320,000 |
With a judgment-based confirmed balance of KRW 8,800,000 and a current request of KRW 9,000,000, the difference is +KRW 200,000.
If payment is due and cash available now is KRW 3,000,000, the shortfall is KRW 5,800,000.
A smaller collection-based balance does not allow you to replace an agreed judgment basis unilaterally.
Credit order alone can change the total
Assume a KRW 1,000,000 rate fee, a KRW 2,000,000 minimum, no cap, a KRW 1,500,000 retainer credit and added 10% VAT.
The same starting rate fee produces three different totals depending on the confirmed order.
Limits → credit → tax
KRW 2,000,000 − 1,500,000 leaves KRW 500,000; adding KRW 50,000 VAT gives KRW 550,000.
Credit → limits → tax
After the credit reduces the rate fee to zero, the KRW 2,000,000 minimum applies; adding KRW 200,000 VAT gives KRW 2,200,000.
Limits → tax → credit
The minimum plus VAT totals KRW 2,200,000; subtracting the KRW 1,500,000 gross payment credit gives KRW 700,000.
The third credit is a gross payment amount, while the first two are net credits in this example.
Matching displayed numbers do not establish equivalent contractual treatment.
This single-agreement model does not automatically reconcile progressive rates, multiple cases or court levels, or separate credits across instalments.
How to review the contract and invoice
- Select one civil agreement and record the actual remuneration clause and definition of economic benefit.
- Choose the contractual judgment, settlement, collection, defence or custom base and confirm the treatment of interest.
- Verify the rate, minimum, cap, creditable retainer and operation order, keeping the tax convention consistent.
- Isolate prior success-fee payments and enter the current invoice request, review date, due date and cash available now.
- Check the trigger date and unresolved terms, confirm the contract inputs and review the bill, balance and hold reasons.
- Copy or save the review TXT and ask the lawyer to explain the base, credit, tax and any difference alongside the source documents.
The report contains the selected basis, input details, order, verification status and arithmetic.
It does not replace a contract or tax invoice and is not proof of a legal payment obligation.
Recalculate when the contract inputs or invoice change instead of reusing an outdated report.
Cash before collection and practical scenarios
Judgment obtained, money not yet collected
If the confirmed trigger is final judgment and the due date precedes the next expected collection date, the confirmed outstanding balance is shown as cash needed before collection.
Future collection does not increase cash available now or erase the present funding gap.
Only part of the award was collected
Enter only confirmed collected principal and interest, then compare it with the judgment-based assumption.
For fees billed on successive collections, first establish whether the review covers cumulative amounts or only the current instalment, and align prior payments and credits to that scope.
Unknown collection date or same-day payment
An unknown next collection date leaves the pre-collection cash figure pending.
The next collection date must be on or after the review date; an earlier date is an input error.
If collection is on or before the due date, that reference figure is zero, without guaranteeing intraday receipt and transfer sequencing.
The current cash shortfall is calculated separately from payment due now and cash available now.
The tool does not calculate new delay interest, predict enforcement success or solvency, estimate insurance reimbursement or calculate whole-lawsuit net recovery.
For a broader budget, transfer only the confirmed success-fee amount as a cost and avoid counting it twice.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a statutory standard success-fee rate?
This tool does not prescribe an appropriate or market-standard rate for civil success fees.
Enter the actual agreement and verify the minimum, cap and tax convention as well.
Does winning without collection mean no success fee?
Final judgment and actual collection are different events.
The tool does not declare zero payment or a payment obligation before you verify the contractual trigger.
Is interest always included in the base?
You select interest inclusion for judgment and collection bases.
Settlement and custom entries are verified totals, so interest from other fields is not added again.
Should the retainer also be entered as a prior payment?
Do not enter a credited retainer a second time as a prior success-fee payment.
Prior payments contain only success fees already paid, including their tax.
Must another 10% be added when the contract does not mention VAT?
Separate tax-law valuation from the contractual right to charge additional VAT.
VAT Act Article 29(7) provides a rule for unclear consideration, while this tool can hold payment confirmation until the contractual invoice treatment is clarified.
Is this the attorney fee recoverable from the opposing party?
Private remuneration and attorney remuneration included in litigation costs are different calculations.
The Article 3 schedule is not used as a private success-fee cap here, and opposing-party cost recovery is not added.
Does a difference or excess payment establish a refund?
It is an arithmetic difference based on your entries.
Refund rights, contractual validity and judicial reduction require separate review and are not automatically determined.
How is zero before the due date different from a hold?
Zero due today before the due date can coexist with a confirmed outstanding balance.
A hold means terms, the triggering event, dates or tax remain unverified, so payable amounts have not been confirmed.
Official Korean sources and the 2026 verification basis
Sources were checked on 2026-11-16 through the National Law Information OPEN API, including current statute and precedent details.
Recheck subsequent changes and whether the stated effective version applies to the agreement and events being reviewed.
- Civil Act Articles 105 and 686: Law ID 001706, MST 284415, Act No. 21454, promulgated and effective 2026-03-17.
Relevant rules on agreement and mandate remuneration.
- VAT Act Articles 29 and 30: Law ID 001571, MST 276117, Act No. 21065, promulgated 2025-10-01, effective 2026-01-02.
Supply value, consideration and the 10% tax rate.
- Rules on Inclusion of Attorney Remuneration in Litigation Costs, Article 3: Law ID 005866, MST 225413, Supreme Court Rule No. 2936, promulgated and effective 2020-12-28.
Distinguishes litigation-cost inclusion from private remuneration.
- Supreme Court 2022Da293937, 2023-08-31: Precedent ID 238659.
A specific property-division fee agreement and its economic-benefit calculation.
- Supreme Court en banc 2016Da35833, 2018-05-17: Precedent ID 197035.
Agreed remuneration as the starting point and exceptional restriction where it is unjustifiably excessive; not a source of an automatic reduction rate.
Reconfirm the actual base, interest scope, deemed-success clauses, credit order, tax invoice and payment dates from case documents.
Criminal success fees, reconciliation across several cases or court levels, judicial reductions and refund claims are outside this single civil-agreement audit.
Use the review to confirm the invoice and payment plan
Start with the contractual definition of the base and the triggering event, then check the number.
Prepare the agreement and actual collection records, align the inputs above, and ask for a specific explanation of any unresolved terms using the review report.
After clarification, recalculate the balance and cash required at the due date.