Enter the roster and confirmed contract terms, then calculate. Partial entries show known subtotals and remaining checks.
Compare attendance and payroll software against the billable roster
A price per employee is only one part of an attendance or payroll software invoice.
Purchased licenses may remain unchanged after an employee leaves, archived accounts may be chargeable, and payroll features or access-device connections may cost extra.
This calculator applies two contracts to the same billing-month roster and required scope, then compares billable seats, monthly invoices, initial cash payment and a constant-roster twelve-month scenario.
It does not retrieve current vendor prices or recommend a product.
Use confirmed terms from the actual quotes rather than treating the fictional example as a market price.
Three questions to resolve before signing
- Which active employees, archived accounts or purchased licenses enter the bill?
- Does the quote cover separate administrators, sites, devices and required attendance, payroll and export features?
- Do annual prepayment and the minimum commitment require more cash despite a lower monthly equivalent?
This is contract billing arithmetic, not a calculation of wages, overtime, statutory headcount or productivity benefits.
Use the HRIS adoption ROI calculator for process time savings and investment recovery.
Use the payroll outsourcing break-even calculator for the separate decision between internal payroll work and an external service.
Distinguish active staff, archived accounts and purchased licenses
Roster-based billing
Start with active staff and select whether archived former-employee accounts are chargeable under each contract.
Keeping historical records does not itself prove that an archive fee applies.
Leave the policy unresolved when the link between account status and billing status has not been confirmed.
Purchased-license billing
Enter each plan’s purchased licenses for every roster period instead of assuming that active staff determine the charge.
Deactivating an employee does not automatically reduce the purchased-license quantity.
A license quantity below active staff is treated as an unsuitable usage condition.
Shopl’s official FAQ, checked on 2026-11-19, describes charging from the day a member is added or restored and excluding the member from the day after deletion or departure processing.
Login activity or attendance records should not replace the contract’s billing event.
Shiftee’s official payment guide separately defines licenses as the maximum number of employees that can be active and explains that payment licenses may need adjustment after deactivation.
A vendor name alone is insufficient evidence for selecting the billable-roster formula.
Cover the billing month without gaps or overlapping periods
Select the billing month, then divide it into periods during which the relevant roster remains unchanged.
Both the start day and end day are included.
Days 1–15 followed by 16–30 cover a thirty-day month; 1–15 followed by 15–30 count day 15 twice.
A missing or overlapping day prevents a final comparison because daily charges and monthly peaks cannot be established reliably.
The calendar denominator is 28 days in an ordinary February, 29 in a leap-year February, and 30 or 31 in other months.
Translate billing events into period boundaries
If an account is chargeable through day 15 and excluded from day 16, split the ledger at that boundary.
Employment dates and software account-addition or deletion dates may differ.
Use the event specified by the contract, and enter anonymous aggregate counts in no more than 31 periods.
No employee name, date of birth or biometric record is required.
A blank active, archive, administrator, site or device quantity means unresolved; zero means confirmed absence.
Separate administrator quantities must not duplicate administrators already counted as employee seats.
If administrators use ordinary employee licenses, include them in that roster or license quantity and avoid adding a second administrator charge for the same account.
Site and device quantities are held constant throughout the month in this model.
Choose daily, snapshot, monthly peak or a confirmed previous-period count
- Daily: calculate the seat charge for each day and prorate it over the actual calendar month, using the confirmed proration rule.
- Snapshot: use the roster or purchased-license quantity in the period containing the selected snapshot day.
- Monthly peak: use the largest simultaneously chargeable quantity. Do not add an active-staff maximum from one day to an archive maximum from another.
- Confirmed previous period: enter the total billable count agreed with each provider. The current month cannot reconstruct the previous period’s maximum.
Snapshot and peak options apply only when the actual contract uses those definitions.
Shopl’s current official FAQ does not establish previous-month peak billing as its standard rule.
A manually confirmed previous-period count must already reflect that contract’s archive and license definitions.
Confirm the billing time zone and the effective day of addition, restoration and deletion before translating the account report into periods.
Exact daily proration and truncating a period ratio to two decimals
Exact proration multiplies each period’s seat charge by period days ÷ calendar days and adds the results without intermediate rounding.
The ratio-truncation option first joins consecutive periods with the same seat charge, then truncates each resulting day ratio to two decimal places before multiplying the charge.
For example, 19/31 is approximately 0.6129, but its truncated ratio is 0.61.
Shiftee’s official example uses this type of truncation, so a simple daily average should not be described as universally identical to a vendor invoice.
Splitting an unchanged ledger must not create a discount
Consecutive periods with an identical seat charge are combined before calculating their ratio.
This prevents an artificial result change caused only by dividing the same roster into additional rows.
If the real contract groups truncation differently, or the unit rate or plan changes during the month, obtain a separate provider calculation.
An unresolved proration rule keeps the final invoice pending.
A weighted-average billable-seat figure may be fractional.
Do not round it up to a whole employee and multiply by a unit price.
For a tiered contract, applying the rate table to average headcount can differ from applying the table to each day’s quantity and then prorating the resulting charges.
The calculator follows the latter order.
Apply minimum seats before included seats and tier rates
Seat formulas
Billable roster = active staff + chargeable archived accounts, or confirmed purchased licenses
Contract seats = max(billable roster, minimum seats)
Paid seats = max(contract seats − included seats, 0)
Flat charge = paid seats × seat rate
Graduated charge = min(paid seats, first-tier limit) × seat rate + max(paid seats − first-tier limit, 0) × next rate
Minimum seats are a contractual purchase floor; included seats are already covered by the base fee.
They are separate conditions and should not share one input.
Daily billing applies the seat floor to each day.
Applying it only to average monthly staff can omit charges for lower-headcount periods.
A volume tier applies the next rate to every paid seat once the first-tier limit is exceeded.
Graduated pricing applies the next rate only to seats beyond that limit.
The tier limit is measured after included seats have been deducted.
Verify the meaning of any zero rate or zero tier quantity against the quote.
More than two tiers, or employee groups with different unit rates, need a separate calculation rather than an average price forced into this model.
Check administrator, site, device and required-feature charges
Each quantity axis can be confirmed as included without an additional charge, metered above an allowance, blocked above its allowance, or unresolved.
Metered overage rounds the excess quantity up to complete billing blocks.
A partially used block still costs one block.
For example, two devices with one included device and KRW 3,000 for each extra device produce a KRW 3,000 overage.
A contract including two devices has no overage for the same demand.
Quantity and feature formulas
Overage blocks = ceil(max(quantity − included quantity, 0) ÷ block size)
Axis monthly fee = overage blocks × block price
Monthly pretax = max(base + seat fees + axis fees + required-feature fees, monthly minimum)
Select the required attendance, payroll and data-export features once in the shared demand.
For each plan, included means no additional charge, extra means a confirmed monthly fee, and unsupported makes the plan unsuitable.
A cheaper attendance-only product is not selected as the lower-cost equivalent of a plan that must also provide payroll.
Unselected features are not added automatically, so do not omit a feature that the actual workflow needs.
Check whether hardware purchases, connectivity and external integrations are fully represented by the initial and recurring amounts you enter.
Read tax uplift, initial fees, annual prepayment and commitment amounts
Both language versions use KRW without currency conversion.
Money inputs are whole won, and the directly entered tax uplift accepts two decimal places.
For a tax-inclusive quote, explicitly enter zero uplift rather than adding the same tax twice.
For a tax-exclusive quote, enter the confirmed applicable percentage.
Article 30 of the Korean VAT Act states a 10% rate, but this contextual legal reference is not an automatic default for every quote.
The calculator does not determine taxability, exemption, input-tax deductibility or foreign tax treatment.
The invoice equals pretax amount × (1 + entered uplift/100), rounded at the final whole-won stage.
The initial fee is outside the monthly minimum and is added once to the first invoice before uplift and rounding.
A monthly-payment twelve-month scenario adds the first invoice and eleven recurring invoices.
Annual prepayment uses the actual discounted monthly-equivalent quote and collects twelve months of recurring fees plus the initial fee at the start.
A low annual monthly equivalent can therefore require a much larger initial cash payment.
The twelve-month scenario is not a future invoice guarantee
It repeats the current roster mix, within-month proportions and prices.
The minimum-commitment amount repeats the same conditions over the entered commitment; it is not a cancellation penalty.
Monthly commitments accept 1–60 months; annual commitments must be multiples of 12 within that range.
Mid-month plan changes, future hiring or departures, annual license additions or reductions, account substitution, refunds and renewal settlements require separate contract review.
Fictional worked example: average 15 seats versus a 22-seat snapshot
In the 30-day month 2026-11, days 1–15 have 10 active staff and 2 archived accounts, while days 16–30 have 20 active staff and 2 archived accounts.
The snapshot is day 30; demand also includes one separate administrator, one site and two devices, with attendance and payroll required.
A uses exact daily proration with free archives; B uses the snapshot with chargeable archives.
Both confirm zero minimum seats, included seats, monthly minimum and tax uplift, a KRW 1,000 seat rate, monthly payment and a 12-month commitment.
These are fictional arithmetic inputs, not actual vendor selling prices.
Fictional A and B contract invoices in KRW using the same roster ledger| Measure | A daily, archives free | B snapshot, archives billed |
|---|
| Billable seats | 15 average | 22 |
| Base fee | 10,000 | 5,000 |
| Seat fee | 15,000 | 22,000 |
| Device overage | 3,000 | 0 |
| Monthly invoice | 28,000 | 27,000 |
| First invoice including initial fee | 33,000 | 27,000 |
| Constant-roster twelve-month total | 341,000 | 324,000 |
A has a KRW 5,000 initial fee and B has none.
A includes the administrator and site, includes one device and charges KRW 3,000 for the second; B includes all quantity axes and required features.
When both contracts are confirmed and suitable, B’s twelve-month scenario is KRW 17,000 lower.
With the same employee unit-rate structure, adding the same active staff to every period does not reverse the advantage within the +1,000-person search range.
Work from the contract to the result in six steps
- Prepare an anonymous ledger for the same billing month and time zone, covering every calendar day.
- Enter nonduplicated administrator accounts, sites, devices and required features once.
- Confirm each plan’s billing basis, roster or license source, archive policy, proration rule and seat allowances.
- Check rates, tiers, axis limits, feature fees, base and minimum fees, initial fee, tax uplift and commitment against the quote.
- Resolve pending conditions and unsuitable scope before comparing monthly fees, first payment and twelve-month totals.
- Save the TXT result and checklist, then request written confirmation of the billable quantity and terms from the provider.
Use the fictional example to learn the input structure and verify the worked result.
Returning from the example restores your previous input and editing position.
After changing a contract value, calculate again instead of using an outdated result.
On mobile, use the result’s edit action and switch between A and B while checking that the shared roster remains unchanged.
Interpret partial amounts and the first headcount crossover
A known pretax subtotal contains confirmed charge components only.
It does not mean that an unknown feature fee or minimum is free, and it is not an upper bound for the contract.
Unsupported required features or quantities above a hard limit make a plan unsuitable.
Pending and unsuitable plans are excluded from a lower-cost selection; both plans must be confirmed and suitable before a difference is shown.
Keep a confirmed zero distinct from an unresolved blank.
Crossover adds the same staff to every roster period
The experiment adds +0 through +1,000 active staff to every period and finds the first integer addition that reverses a strict twelve-month cost advantage.
A tie alone is not a reversal.
When the existing roster varies, do not reinterpret the added count as one particular day’s total headcount.
Tiered pricing can create later reversals, so the first change is not a permanent break-even threshold.
The search requires both plans to use roster quantities with exact daily, snapshot or monthly-peak billing.
Confirmed previous-period counts, purchased-license billing and truncated day ratios do not establish how added active staff change contracted quantities, so crossover remains pending.
No reversal within the search range is not proof that one plan stays cheaper at every possible scale.
Administrator, site and device quantities and required features stay fixed during the experiment.
Practical scenarios and model limits
A shop with seasonal hiring
Separate periods before and after new staff arrive or depart, then compare daily and snapshot contracts.
Check archive charges and the effective reduction of purchased licenses separately to identify recurring charges that a simple headcount comparison misses.
An operator connecting multiple sites and devices
The same employee count can produce different charges because of site and device allowances or billing blocks.
Check duplicated administrator seats and payroll add-ons, then prepare cash for an annual upfront payment.
This model assumes a constant seat rate within the billing month and constant monthly axis and required-feature fees.
Do not pool independent site allowances or average employee groups with different rates.
Per-employee invoice rounding, multiple tax rates, combined promotions, refunds, penalties, mid-month plan changes and separate hardware financing are outside scope.
Contracts beyond the supported amount or quantity ranges need a separate provider invoice calculation.
Frequently asked questions
Does deactivating a former employee immediately reduce the bill?
It depends on the contract.
Purchased-license billing can require a separate license reduction after account deactivation.
Confirm the effective deletion day and payment quantity before entering each period.
Should administrators be included in employee seats?
Shopl’s official guidance describes the same fee for administrators who do not clock in.
When the contract includes them in ordinary employee seats, include them in the roster or licenses without charging the same account again.
The separate-administrator input is for additional nonduplicated billable accounts.
Does daily proration always use thirty days?
No.
It uses the selected month’s actual 28, 29, 30 or 31 days.
A fixed thirty-day denominator or separate per-employee truncation differs from this model and needs provider verification.
Is previous-month peak the standard Shopl rule?
The official FAQ checked on 2026-11-19 describes daily use-based proration.
Use a confirmed previous-period count only when your actual contract specifies that condition.
It is not a universal provider rule.
Are blank prices treated as free?
No.
A blank is unresolved and keeps the final comparison pending.
Enter zero or choose included only after confirming that the charge is absent; a known partial subtotal is not the final invoice.
Does annual prepayment provide a refund when staff decrease?
The tool does not determine refund rights or amounts.
Shopl’s annual guidance describes account substitution without a refund after a decrease, so check the actual contract.
Read the first cash payment alongside the constant-roster twelve-month scenario.
Should I add a 10% uplift to a tax-inclusive quote?
Do not add tax that is already included.
Confirm zero uplift for a tax-inclusive amount, or verify the percentage applicable to a tax-exclusive quote.
Taxability and deductibility require separate tax review.
Does no crossover mean I should keep the same plan indefinitely?
It means no strict advantage reversal was found in this particular +1,000-person experiment.
Different features, devices, rate tiers or commitments can change the conclusion.
Re-enter confirmed terms when signing or renewing.
Official evidence, dates and contract recheck list
Official sources were checked on 2026-11-19; Shiftee’s payment guide was updated on 2026-07-30.
The public pages establish billing structures, not the fictional prices used here.
The Korean VAT Act, current law ID001571, MST276117, Article 30, effective 2026-01-02, was checked through the National Law Information OPEN API.
Its 10% contextual rate is not automatically applied by the calculator.
Confirm the snapshot day, time zone, addition and deletion effective dates, archive policy, purchased-license adjustment, administrator overlap, shared site limits, device integrations, required features, tax presentation, minimum seats, commitment, annual quantity changes, refunds and export access in writing.
Recheck public terms quarterly and actual contract terms at every comparison or renewal.
Take the billable quantities and open questions back to the provider
A useful comparison connects the unit price to the roster and included scope.
Save the TXT result with quantities, terms, fictional-example status and the recheck list, then ask the provider to price the same case.
Resolve missing conditions before treating an amount as a complete contract comparison.
Continue to workflow savings and HRIS investment recovery